The American Chestnut Story
Early in the 20th century, chestnut blight was unwittingly introduced to the United States, with the importation of Asian chestnut trees by the Bronx Zoo. American chestnut trees (Castanea dentata) had no resistance to this fungal disease, and it quickly devastated the American chestnut population. Chestnut blight doesn’t kill the whole tree, but it does kill the top growth. Trees may re-sprout repeatedly from the roots, but they almost never get mature enough to bear fruit.
The Chinese chestnut (C. mollissima) and Japanese chestnut (C. crenata) are resistant to chestnut blight, but their nuts aren’t as sweet as those of the American chestnut. In an effort to bring back the American chestnut and its tasty fruit, breeding programs are underway that integrate small amounts of Asian chestnut DNA into the American chestnut genome. The goal is to combine the blight resistance of the Asian nuts with the flavor of the American nut.
Chestnuts in the Wild
If you happen upon mature chestnuts in the woods today, they’re probably feral, Asian chestnuts. And while they may not be as sweet and delicious as our native chestnut is rumored to be, they’re still worth foraging for. Humans aren’t the only animals that appreciate ripe chestnuts; you’ll need to get to them before the squirrels, raccoons, bears, and deer. As nuts ripen in early to mid fall, the green, spiny, outer casing opens to reveal the nuts within. This is the perfect time to harvest, while the open fruit is still on the tree. Shortly thereafter, the fruit falls from the trees and the early forager gets the chestnut. It may be you, it may be Bambi. I encourage you to be first in line.
In addition to chestnut blight, chestnut lovers should be aware of the chestnut maggot. A small hole in a chestnut indicates that a larva has crawled out of the nut, and burrowed into the ground to overwinter. The good news is that the hole indicates the maggot is gone. The bad news is that a nut without a hole may, or may not, have a maggot inside.
Chestnuts in Your Kitchen
If you have time to process your chestnuts right away, look for bugs and remove them. If you don’t have time to cook with your chestnuts right away, store them in the freezer, lest maggots exit the nuts onto your kitchen counter. When you thaw them, clean out any frozen insects, unless you crave the extra protein Make an X on the flat side of each nut with a serrated knife. (The serrated edge gives you a better grip on the nut.) Place the chestnuts on a cookie sheet and roast them for 25 minutes at 400°. Opening the skin of the nut allows steam to escape during roasting, and prevents the chestnuts from exploding in the oven. The skin peels back from the X and comes off easily when the nuts are still warm. Peeling becomes more difficult as the nuts cool. You can zap them in the microwave to re-warm them and make the peeling easier.
Before you try chestnuts in a recipe, try eating them plain. They’re moist, rich, and dense. Sort of like a mini dessert potato.
Roasted chestnuts are a classic stuffing ingredient. They also make a wonderful savory soup and a sweet, light mousse. And because chestnuts contain more starch than any other nut, they are often served as a vegetable (hence my earlier potato reference) or ground into flour. And once you’ve made chestnut flour there’s no telling what you’ll make: polenta, pasta, pound cake…so many possibilities.
Andrew Morgan says
Wondering about chestnuts I picked up – one I tried was fairly bitter – poisonrin need of cooking?
Hi Andrew, are you sure it was a chestnut and not a horse chestnut? Horse chestnuts are considered toxic, and can be bitter. The nuts look similar, but the outer shells look very different. If you still have the shell, try googling “chestnut shell” and “horse chestnut shell” and see which one you found. Without seeing the nut shell, I can’t say for sure what the problem is, but bitter flavor is often an indication that something shouldn’t be eaten.
Andrew Morgan says
Thank you Yes bitter and toxic yes not for eating. Guess this bag of nuts goes back to nature.
Theresa S says
Hi, I bought a bag of Italian chestnuts from a neighbor, did what she suggested but the chestnuts still had maggots in them. Like… Whole maggots. Was this a huge waste of time, did I do something wrong or do people just eat the maggots anyway? 🥴
What did your neighbor tell you to do? Was it specifically to get rid of the maggots? Lots of chestnuts have maggots in them. If you bag the nuts and put them in the freezer for a few days, the maggots will leave the nuts and you can get rid of them pretty easily. Some people DO eat the maggots, but I don’t.